Hating feminists as virtue-signaling

After the Vancouver Women’s Library was attacked by “queer” anti-feminists, even more anti-feminists started jumping on the bandwagon and writing social media commentary condemning the library.

I read several comments by people calling for feminist books to be banned who did not seem likely to have ever actually read the books in question. I believe the reason why these people are calling for feminist books to be banned without ever having read them is because they are virtue-signaling.

There is a distinct culture that has formed out of the toxic soup of neoliberal “queer” culture and anti-feminism that has taken over what is supposed to be the political left. (I do not believe these people are actually on the left, but they are considered to be the left, unfortunately.) For the purposes of this blog post, I will call them radiqueers, short for radical queers. One of the things radiqueers delight in doing is hating feminists. They claim to be feminists themselves, but their views align perfectly with patriarchy, and they fail to recognize this because they refuse to listen to actual feminists or apply any critical thinking to their political positions. Because shutting down feminists is one of the goals of radiqueer culture, anytime they tweet or comment about wanting feminists shut down it serves as a way for them to show their group membership and virtue-signal to their fellow group members. It is not an intellectual disagreement with the information that feminists present, it is a performance to demonstrate their group membership. It’s a bit like making sure to sit with the cool kids in the cafeteria instead of the geeks.

Here I will show you what I mean by discussing one of the books that the radiqueers want removed from the Vancouver Women’s Library


via Hating feminists as virtue-signaling — Purple Sage

Petition: Protect Feminist Books at Vancouver Women’s Library

A book-banning campaign by Gays Against Gentrification (GAG) is demanding the Vancouver Woman’s Library (VWL) remove and ban over twenty feminist books from their collection. These works — written by renowned women authors who have a long history of engaging in critical analysis against the oppression of women as class — focus on female exploitation, male supremacy, violence against women, reproductive freedom, lesbian identity, women’s health and buddhist mindfulness. As a matter of principle and in defense of freedom of speech and thought, no library should ever ban any books under any circumstance – especially ones written by and for women at the VWL. As fascism takes deeper root throughout the world, it is more important than ever that any attempt to silence women in their struggle for liberation is resisted by all, at every moment. We urge VWL to keep these books on their shelves.


This petition will be delivered to:

  • Vancouver Women’s Library


Sign the petition here


Targeted harassment by trans activists

A butterfly's diary

Trans activists are not happy. In recent days they have started a couple of petitions aimed at preventing a talk by Julie Bindel at the Working Class Movement Library in Salford as well as at stopping the broadcasting of a BBC programme called “Transgender Kids: Who Knows Best?” to be diffused on 12 January on BBC Two. They have also targeted the site Feminist Current (if you don’t visit it, do: one of the best feminist sites out there), which resulted in it being taken down on Thursday night. And they have no problem in targeting individuals, such as this stream of attacks on gnc_centric, a detransitioned lesbian, which has been defended by some on Tumblr.

There is nothing new here: attempts to no-platform Bindel occur just about every time she is due to give a talk, even when the talks have got nothing to do with transgender issues…

View original post 691 more words

Sisters (can’t) Speak: A response to the Wellington Zinefest organisers from the Zinefest des Refusés!

‘They provided a second reason to exclude me, too.

“We have already formed a working relationship with InsideOUT – they co-hosted Queer my Zine with us as part of Zinefest meets Matchbox this month – and it would be a conflict of interest to have you be part of Zinefest, due to the piece you wrote on your blog that attacked their organisation.

“We feel that your presence at zinefest would jeopardise the safety of our queer and trans artists, people we have worked hard this year to protect and create a safe space for.”

‘This refers to an article I published on my blog in October, which challenges InsideOUT and RainbowYOUTH. It includes a list of questions requesting more information about how both organisatons are addressing different problematic aspects of gender identity politics. For example, one thing I mention is how there are clear statistical patterns now showing who is undergoing transition and sex reassignment. One strong pattern is pre-adolescent boys – even pre-schooers – who do not conform to gender norms or exhibit typically “masculine” behaviour. They might like wearing dresses, or playing with toys marketed at girls. Transitioning, for many of these boys, means sterilisation. So one question I posed to InsideOUT and RainbowYOUTH, was, in sum – what are you doing to ensure that your work isn’t faciliatating eugenics? Considering that both organisations are involved with the medication of gender non-conforming young people, whichever way you look at it, this is a legitimate question and concern.’

writing by renee

Though I’ve never had a stall before, I love the Wellington Zinefest and look forward to it each year. I’ve got a pile of zines at home that I’ve bought, swapped, collected and enjoyed from markets over the years. Through the art supply shop I work at, I sponsored the Wellington Zinefest 2015 gladly, with free prize packs and zine-making kits. It’s a uniquely accessible and inclusive affordable, no-frills, not for profit, grassroots event. I take heart in the fact that it’s there and allows us Wellingtonians to share and exchange creative work and ideas – even challenging ones – so freely.

This year, on October 25, I finally registered and paid for my first very own stall at the Wellington Zinefest – after over a year of preparing my books. This is them: Free West Papua 101; How Freedom’s Won, and Sisters Speak.

Freedom zines. So imagine my surprise when, over a fortnight after my…

View original post 1,599 more words

Interview about Female Erasure book – Thistle Pettersen, Singer/Songwriter

“Interview about Female Erasure book” from WLRN by Ruth Barrett, Elizabeth McKeown. Released: 2016. Track .

Source: Interview about Female Erasure book – Thistle Pettersen, Singer/Songwriter

Anti-lesbian shitheads on Twitter

Purple Sage

screenshot June 8

So this idiot took a poll to see if lesbians are attracted to “women” or “their genitals.” Because in crazy transgenderland, these things can be separated. In real life, of course, women and their genitals are actually connected together in one piece, and lesbians are attracted to both.

When this person’s friends answer the poll, the conclusion is of course that lesbians fancy “women,” a word that in transgenderland can include absolutely anyone, regardless of their sex. Also, TERFs should get some fleshlights because we are just into genitals. (I had to ask someone what “minge” means. Apparently it means “pussy” in the U.K. I definitely prefer “fanny.” Anyway…)

A fleshlight is a sex toy for men consisting of a fake vagina in a hollow tube.


This person is suggesting that TERFs would enjoy playing with this toy. Now, I don’t think this person actually believes this—I think they’re…

View original post 822 more words



Dear Editor,

We are writing to express our great appreciation and support of the Morning Star for its exceptional courage and solidarity with women everywhere in publishing two recent articles [here and here] highlighting the problems of current political dogma regarding gender identity.

Along with the writers of those articles, we are watching with some alarm as the few hard-won rights and protections that women have managed to gain are being eroded through political and social developments that will have very serious consequences for women indeed.

We very much appreciate your efforts in giving a platform for a sex-class based analysis of women’s position, in the face of the convergence of neoliberal individualism and alienation from class consciousness which we believe is very clearly at the heart of gender identity politics.

Those of us who speak out in defence of women are no strangers to the particular viciousness of the backlash that such speech is invariably met with.

We applaud the Morning Star for taking a courageous stand against the erasure of women as a class, and stand in solidarity with you in the face of this inevitable backlash.

Please note that some signatories were only able to provide their initials, for fear of possible repercussions were they to be identified. This, sadly, reflects the climate of fear and intimidation that we are currently living in.

Yours faithfully,

Laura Akers
Tracy Allard
Simone Andrea
Tessa Anne
Sam Antix
Temple Ardinger
Michelle Arouet
A. B.
A. M. B.
H. B.
S. Baillie
Gerdien Baker
D. Ball
Ruthanna Barnett
Josephine Bartosch
Ali Jean Batts
J. Beard
Monika Beatty
Carly Bell
Grace Restauro Belleveau
Courtney Belyea
Ophelia Benson
Cheryl Lynn Bergen
Maritza Y. Bermudez
Magdalen Berns
Elisa Beth
Jennifer Bilek
A. Billows
Sylvia Black
Lisa Blank
C. L. Blythe
Katherine Boyd
Aleta Lisa Brady
Sharon Brandon
L. Brice
S. Britton.
Ginny Brown
Louise A. Brown
Tim Brown
Juliana Brustik
Sam Brydon
Poppy Taylor Brydon
Kasandra C.
Lila C.
M. Calder
Linda Calder Trapp
Helen Cameron
Caroline Campbell
Giovanna S. Capone
T. Carson
Mary Cellaigh
Elaine Charkowski
Jennifer Chavez
Adelaide Ciao
C. K. A. & Big Ocean Women
Stephanie Cleveland
Lucy Coghill
Sinéad Connolly
Angie Conroy
M. Conroy
Georgia Constantinou
Allen Corben
Catherine Costello
Brandi Cowtan
Nikki Craft
Sophia Crews
Marie Solange Crosswell
Rebecca Cummings
C. Dacke
Hanna Dahlberg
Joan Dark
Janie Davies
Stephanie Davies Arai
Cynthia Dehesa
Tracie Warden Dengá
Robert Doublin
T. Duckett
Katherine Dunne
T. Drake
Jennifer Drew
Katharine Edgar
Charlotte Edwards
J. Egerton
J. England
Donna J. Every
Jessica Feijoo
Elsa Field
Anna Fisher
Sarah Fletcher
Steph Free
K. Frost
Nina Gadson
D. Gallagher
Jane Galloway
Lorna Garano
Michelle Garcia
Gabriel Garza
W. Gibbons
Emma Gibson
L. Giddings
P. Giddings
C. Gillespie.
Evelina Giobbe
Kate Glle
Karen Goode
Steph Gr
Erin Graham
Kate Graham
J. Green
J. T. Green
Ruth Greenberg
Lucy Griffin
Ellen Grogan
Jacqueline Gullion
L. H.
M. H.
Sareyeh Hadian
Shoshana Handel
Sally Hansen
Lynne Harne
C Harries.
A. Harrison
Rebecca Harrison
Lynette Hartsell
Andy Healey
Ruth Henderson
Meg Henson Scales
J. Hickinbotham
Eleanor Hill
Lori Hirt
Chante Shirelle Holsey
Geraldine Homewood
Barbara Hughes
A. Hunt
Elaine Hutton
C. I.
Peggy Drake Imhoff
Jen Izaakson
J. J.
Laura Jane
Sheila Jeffreys
Derrick Jensen
Maggie Jihan
R. Jinks
S. Jinks
Sarah Johnson
A. Jones
Sarah Jones
Trace K.
S. Kadir
Kellie-Jay Keen-Minshull
Lierre Keith
Rachel King
Wendy Knight
Ksenija Kordic
Maria Kuznetsova
Danielle L.
Lee Lakeman
Michelle Landers
P. Lane
Megan C. Langreck
Rho Laway
A. Lawson
Nancy Leaman
Sue Leigh
Amanda Gracey Lesiatoi
Kathleen Levinstein
Rachel Lima
Lauren Lindsey
Barbara Link
Lance Link
Owen Lloyd
Julia Long
Cathy Love
Susi Lowndes
Peggy Luhrs
Jill Lyall
J. M.
M. M.
Megan Diana Mackin
S. Malik
L. A. Mallett
Cassia Mangin
Melinda Mann
Lisa Marchetti
Sam Marshall
Meike Matarazzo
Susan Matthews
Ginger McArdle
Jennifer C. McCarthy
Leah McCaskill
Paul J. McDonough
Steve McEvoy
Karey Mcglynn
Elizabeth McKeown
Moira McGee
Jackie Mearns
Camilla Mills
Tina Minkowitz
Kathy Miriam
Jonah Mix
Keely Emerine Mix
J. Molloy
Charlie Monomon
Adam Moore
Edrie Moore
Chris Morris
Libby Morrison
Jennifer Murnan
J. N.
P. N.
Pete Newbon
Selma Nieuwoudt
Bo Novak
Corine Nugteren
V. O.
Marina O’Brien
Linda Ohlson
K. K. Olsen
J. O’Neill
P. O’Neill
Lara O’Regan
Pamela O’Shaughnessy
E. Parry
R. Parsons
J. Pearson
Laura Marina Perez
Thistle Pettersen
Sarah Philips
Clare Phillipson
Elizabeth Pickett
Stefania Prigoda
Linda Puck
RadFem Collective
R. A. R.
Louise Raw
Samantha Rea
Natasha Read
Spider Redgold
Rebecca Reilly-Cooper
Louisa Cruz Reinke
Emma Robertson
Jaid Roden
Steven Romero
Jane Roper
Pam Rubin
Serena Rush
M. Russell
F. Ryan
H. S.
L. S.
P. S.
S. S.
Helen Saxby
Richard D. Schmidt
Arthur Sevestre
Jody Shaw
V. Shedlock
Davina Simpson
Mary Lou Singleton
M. Slavidis
Josh Slocum
Laura Smethurst
Michelle Peixinho Smith
Olivia Smith
Pam Smith
Izabela Sowula
Terre Spencer
Francine Sporenda
Gail Stephens
M Stephenson
Roberta Stevenson
K. Stone
S. Stoneman
Caroline Storey
Scarlet Stubbs
Denise Sumpter
Camilla Astrid Strand
Mary Syrett
Julka Szymanska
Tanya Tanner
L. M. Taylor
Hannah Terkes
Nicole Thompson
Liane Timmermann
Transgender Trend
Fiona Tresidder
Lisa Trost
Meagan Tyler
Victoria Vanasco
Katarina Vidovic
Julian Vigo
Kathleen de Vries
L. Wainwright
Marion Wallace
Nicky Wallace
Jen Ward
Lisa Ware
Liz Waterhouse
Lisa J. Whelan
Amanda Whyte
Angela C. Wild
L. Wild
Agnieszka Wilk
C. Williams
Sara Williams
Melody Williams-Daniels
Sarah Wilson
Robyn Wilson-Owen
J. Woodley
Jodie Woodward
Miranda Yardley
Bryony Yost
Anna Zobnina


STC note: the ‘fighting fund’ of the Morning Star (its fundraising project to keep running) has probably been hit by the onslaught of accusations of ‘transphobia’ and worse which it has received.

Please consider helping them out.






Victoria Derbyshire | Is Free Speech At British Universities Under Threat?

Sarah Ditum


On Monday 25 April, I took part in the Victoria Derbyshire show for a discussion about free speech in British universities. Given that the show tried to cover the inner workings of NUS politics, the ad-hoc activism of unofficial no-platforming, the history of the anti-fascist movement on campuses, and free speech as an abstract principle, it all seemed rather overstuffed even at two hours; but I got to sit next to Julie Bindel and Peter Tatchell as though I’m someone who actually does things, which was nice.

Watch a clip of the debate here

View original post

‘Old Women: Shut the Fuck Up.’ and ‘The Greer Fiasco: Oct’15’

In Permanent Opposition writes about how the specific ageism deployed against older women helps power the popularity of calling Germaine Greer irrelevant and transphobic.

Articles here